top of page
Writer's pictureJohn-Michael Scurio

Stories to tell . . .

Eureka Springs is more than just a charming town in the Ozarks; it’s a living museum of architectural styles that have stood the test of time. From the grandeur of Victorian homes to the distinct character of Romanesque structures, the city’s buildings tell a story of innovation, craftsmanship, and a community that embraced architectural trends from across the country and across the pond.

Victorian Elegance

Imagine walking down a street in Eureka Springs in the late 1800s. The town bustling with growth, and the architectural landscape reflects the prosperity of the era. Victorian-style homes, with their intricate detailing and ornate facades, dominate the scene. These houses weren’t just for the wealthy; mass production and the expansion of the railroad made it possible for middle-class families to afford these stylish homes, too, in some cases.

39 Prospect Ave, "Avarana" in Eureka Springs, AR

One of the most fascinating stories from this period involves W.H. Reid, a prominent Chicago banker, who decided to build a summer home in Eureka Springs. He hired Theodore C. Link, a renowned architect known for designing Union Station in St. Louis, to create his retreat. The result was "Avarana," an elegant Colonial Revival home that stood as a symbol of Reid’s success and the architectural sophistication of Eureka Springs.

Architect, Theodore C. Link

The Grandiosity of Second Empire

As you continue your architectural journey, you’ll come across Penn Castle, a house that stands as a monument to the Second Empire style. With its distinctive mansard roof and two-story tower, Penn Castle is one of the most elaborate homes in Eureka Springs. The house was built by a local entrepreneur who wanted to bring a touch of Parisian elegance to the Ozarks.

Penn Castle, 36 Eureka Street - a perfect example of Second Empire architecture

The story goes that the owner, inspired by the grand homes he saw on a trip to Europe, insisted on importing slate from France to cover the roof. This attention to detail and desire for authenticity is what makes Penn Castle a true masterpiece.


Penn Castle once the hub of our town’s social scene, where locals gathered for everything from town meetings to lavish balls. No expense was spared in ensuring that his establishment was not only functional but also a testament to the beauty of Italianate architecture.


After the death of both Major and Mrs. Penn, the house was only owned by a few other families. In the 1950’s, Gerald L.K. Smith, and his wife Elna, bought the house and made it their home. The Smith’s made some changes to the home but were primarily occupied with the founding of The Great Passion Play, and the Elna M. Smith Foundation.

The impressive front portion of the castle includes a balcony that looks to the east. It is the only house on Eureka Street with a balcony facing that direction. That proved very important to Smith, as he bought the house sight unseen after being told about the balcony where he could watch the construction of his Christ of the Ozarks statue from home.


Romanesque Revival

Carroll County Courthouse, Downtown Eureka Springs

As you approach the Carroll County Courthouse, you’re greeted by the imposing presence of Romanesque Revival architecture. This limestone building, with its semi-circular arches and fortress-like appearance, has been a symbol of justice and order in Eureka Springs for over a century.


The courthouse was built during a time when the town was transitioning from a rough-and-tumble frontier settlement to a more established community. The choice of Romanesque Revival was deliberate, conveying strength and stability—a message to both residents and visitors that Eureka Springs was here to stay.


Queen Anne Grandeur

Finally, no architectural tour of Eureka Springs would be complete without marveling at its Queen Anne-style homes. These houses, with their steeply pitched roofs, ornate spindle work, and wrap-around porches, are the epitome of Victorian elegance.

211 Spring Street, Eureka Springs, AR

One such home, located at 211 Spring Street, was built in 1881 for former Arkansas Governor Powell Clayton. Clayton wanted a home that would reflect his status and chose the Queen Anne style for its grandeur and intricate detailing. The house quickly became a local landmark, known for its tall corner tower and elaborate woodwork.


Just down the street, at 253 Spring Street, is the Judge Humphrey House. This home, with its prominent three-story tower and decorative bargeboard, is a textbook example of Queen Anne architecture. It’s said that Judge Humphrey, a man known for his love of the arts, personally oversaw the construction, ensuring that every detail was perfect.

253 Spring Street, Eureka Springs, AR

A Living Legacy

The architecture of Eureka Springs is not just about bricks and mortar; it’s about the people who built these homes, the stories they left behind, and the community that continues to preserve and celebrate this rich heritage. Eureka Springs is timeless! Whether you’re a history buff, an architecture enthusiast, or simply a curious traveler, a visit to Eureka Springs is a journey back in time, where every building has a story to tell.❤️

82 views

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page